OPINION

Opinion: From GH to Y&R, Redeeming Dangerous Soap Villains Is Tricky Business

Comments

There’s a big difference between a standard soap baddie and an irredeemable criminal. Our critic says General Hospital, The Young and the Restless, The Bold and the Beautiful, Beyond the Gates and Days of our Lives need to think twice before scripting crimes that makes true redemption impossible.

Cobalt Blue

A common mistake soaps make is hiring fantastic actors to play despicable characters. The person catches on, and then the show tries to rewrite the backstory to absolve him or her of their crimes.

A prime example of this was GH attempting to whitewash Franco Baldwin’s stalking, assault, murder, etc. by retconning some of his offenses and saying they were caused by a brain tumor when the role was recast with Roger Howarth. The attempt didn’t work because rape is the most unforgivable crime on daytime — we watched the original Franco sexually assault Sam as Jason watched — so it can’t be undone.

(Note: Luke’s rape of Laura in 1979 was off-camera and retconned to a “seduction.” That would not fly today.)

Conversely, murder is routinely forgiven because death can be rewritten by simply bringing the victim(s) back to life. That’s what GH is trying to do with Heather Webber. Her crimes are legion, and the explanation that she’s free because a bum hip gave her cobalt poisoning is nonsense. But her most recent target, Britt Westbourne, returned from the dead, which softens Heather’s offenses, and the writing around her return has been amusing.

Elizabeth: “Wow. You with money.”

Heather (gleeful): “Lots of money!”

She got a lucrative settlement from the bum hip company, which enabled her to buy Wyndemere and that bodes well for future story. GH also wisely has important characters calling Heather on her excuses.

Portia: “Cobalt poisoning doesn’t turn a person into a murderer. She shouldn’t be here having normal conversations with people who haven’t killed people.”

That’s the opinion of most viewers, and voicing it acknowledges our objections. The trick to believable redemption is to have characters we care about reject the criminal’s return, and then slowly have the perp win them over.

Heather: “I know I hurt people.”

Anna: “Killed people.”

Like that.

I prefer soapier baddies, like Drew and Ava, who just entered into the marriage from hell to keep them out of jail.

And you can’t go wrong with a standard issue bitch like Britt, who offends everyone.

Britt: “I’ve changed.”

Elizabeth: “You made two nurses cry yesterday.”

Britt: “It’s a process.”

Dark Matt-er

Y&R could have benefited from GH’s difficult experience recasting Franco with Roger Howarth but, alas, they did not. So here we are with the powerhouse actor coming off a Daytime Emmy win for playing Matt Clark in a story that’s untenable because Matt is a rapist. No amnesia, brain tumor or inexplicable forgiveness from Sharon will undo what we saw Matt do to her in the 1990s, despite the role having been played by a different actor.

Nick speaks for all of us.

Nick: “I do not care how many times Matt insists he has changed. Walking into your home and finding you alone with the monster who terrorized you for so long nearly sent me over the edge.”

Sharon: “It was upsetting to me, too.”

And yet she let him stay. Nick pointed out that if Matt really cared about Sharon’s feelings, he wouldn’t show up unannounced when she’s alone. My vote? Kill Matt in a big cathartic denouement, then bring on his twin if they want to keep Howarth.

Y&R is having better luck with Mariah, although it’s an uphill slog after she kidnapped Devon and Abby’s young son (among other crimes). It helps that Mariah’s wife Tessa has forgiven her for blowing up their family, and she has sought professional help.    

Mariah: “Some days it feels impossible to forgive myself.”

Tessa: “It wasn’t you. It was the voice in your head.”

Uh, okay. If she stays on this path, Mariah could wind up more as a temporary baddie, which lets her stay viable in the Newman orbit and Tessa’s bedroom.

Beyond Redemption?

BTG kicked off in 2025 with Leslie running Laura off the road and later poisoning her IV. They’ve pulled back on Leslie’s villainy by making her the daughter of late Articulette Barbara Mitchell and having her regret some of her actions, but the ladies were nervous when Anita allowed Leslie to attend their recording session with Y&R’s Devon and Lily.

Tracy: “A day we were worried might never happen.”

Anita: “But it’s here, my sisters, and nothing is going to ruin it.”

Leslie (entering): “Hello!”

Shockingly, she didn’t ruin it. Anita gifted Leslie a cherished photo of Barbara as thanks, and they semi-bonded over hearing Barbara’s voice in the studio. If Anita can forgive that villainess, perhaps we can too. My jury’s out.

Anita has no time, however, for Hayley. She called Anita a hypocrite (for defending her grandson Martin’s crime) and snarked that she’s not the queen she claims to be. The matriarch wasn’t having it.

Anita: “You do not want this fight because I will end you. Those secrets you claim to know could end up biting you.”

Hayley is viable because she didn’t succeed in killing Bill. She also has the funniest dialogue on the show (eg: calling motherhood a “cult with diapers”) and is poised to upend the Duprees if she gives birth to Bill’s baby. We can file her under standard soap baddie and enjoy her machinations.

Father Knows Least

To DAYS’ credit, they didn’t ignore EJ’s rape of Sami when they recast the role, they made a story out of it. Johnny learned last year about what his dad did to his mom, and he has struggled with EJ ever since. The convoluted story of EJ bringing Lexie back to life (just so she could die again) added another wrinkle to their fraught relationship.

Johnny: “I know my dad is the reason your mom was taken away again, and I’m sorry.”

Theo: “You don’t need to apologize for your dad.”

Johnny: “We had it out; he basically disowned me. The more I think about everything my dad has done — past and present — the more relieved I am he’s out of my life.”

If it’s true that Dominic is the previously unknown child of Marlena and Stefano, that means he was likely conceived when Marlena was in a coma (ew). But this twist will send fireworks throughout the canvas and has already hit EJ hard since Dominic claims to have controlling interest in DiMera Enterprises. Bottom line: This is a conflict between a rapist and a newbie who may be the product of rape, so the ick factor is high. It also looks like it will be the catalyst for Johnny and Chanel to leave town, which is a bummer because they are the cutest couple on the show.

Chanel (to Johnny): “I want us out. Not just of DiMera, but of Salem.”

Sigh.

Ain’t Too Proud To Beg

For classic troublemaker, look no further than B&B’s Bill Spencer, Jr., who has held the mantle for almost 20 years. However, there is no logical place for this kinder, gentler Sheila despite years of entertaining villainy. Her crimes of murder, kidnapping, baby snatching, arson, etc. could be sprayed away because the victims were either peripheral (sorry, Lance) or survived (Brooke, Taylor). But once Sheila shot Finn and Steffy, she sealed her fate. Her about-face, sweetly filling water glasses at Il Giardino for Deacon and pleading to be part of Finn’s family, made no sense after she tried to kill her own son.

Which brings us to last week, when we watched this stone-cold killer pathetically beg the newly-engaged Deacon to love her.

Sheila: “I am the woman for you. You are the man for me. We’re naughty. We were meant for each other. You are going to be mine. Admit you made a mistake and come back to me.”

I’m sure I’m not the only B&B fan who would rather watch Sheila unleash a swarm of bees!

Hey. It’s only my opinion.

Gates Beyond The Gates Days_680x315 Days of Our Lives GH_680x315 General Hospital BB_680x315 The Bold and the Beautiful The Young and the Restless Banner The Young and the Restless

Conversation

All comments are subject to our Community Guidelines. Soap Opera Digest does not endorse the opinions and views shared by our readers in our comment sections. Our comments section is a place where readers can engage in healthy, productive, lively, and respectful discussions. Offensive language, hate speech, personal attacks, and/or defamatory statements are not permitted. Advertising or spam is also prohibited.

Use left and right arrow keys to navigate between menu items. Use right arrow key to move into submenus. Use escape to exit the menu. Use up and down arrow keys to explore. Use left arrow key to move back to the parent list.

✕
Already have an account?