At Crimson Lights, Lily and Cane ran into each other. Things were awkward at first, but then they became more relaxed as they chatted about their lives. However, things became tense again when he revealed that they'd gotten into a fist-fight and he'd punched Billy. Cane again reminded her to be careful around his brother.

Billy stopped by the Abbott mansion to see Jack. Jack sadly told his brother that Sharon wants a divorce. He then noticed Billy's black eye. Billy lied about how he got it, but Jack realized that it was Cane who gave him the shiner. Billy tried to get Jack to open up about Sharon, but Jack didn't want to talk about it. Jack then asked Billy if he has any misgivings about keeping the paternity of Chloe's baby secret; Billy was confident that he was doing the right thing by keeping quiet about the fact that he's the father. Jack also didn't think it was a good idea for Billy to be dating Cane's ex, Lily. Later, Lily joined Devon for coffee and they discussed Cane and Billy. Lily admitted that she's not acting like "herself" with Billy, which made her a little nervous.

At Restless Style, Phyllis grumbled about Nick being in New York with Sharon. She became anxious as she tried to call Nick and he didn't pick up. He finally did and Phyllis could hear over the line that he and Sharon were out to brunch together. Phyllis became passive aggressive as she complained about all the work she had to do, but then told Nick he didn't need to come home when he offered to. However, he insisted and Sharon supported him. Meanwhile, Phyllis called Brad and informed him of Sharon and Jack's impending divorce. She suggested he go to New York to be with Sharon. After, Brad kept thinking back to his brief relationship with Sharon.... Nick questioned Sharon about what went wrong with Jack.

Billy and Cane arrived at Restless Style for their photo shoots for the "Men We Love" issue. Jack came, too, so he could keep an eye on Phyllis. Cane and Billy were less than thrilled to see the other there. Phyllis also wasn't happy to see Jack there. She assured him that she wasn't trying to stir up trouble by having the brothers there at the same time. She then expressed her sympathies about Jack's impending divorce with Sharon, and informed him that Nick was with Sharon. Later, Jack called Sharon and asked if she told Nick about him forging Victor's diary. Sharon replied that she was keeping Jack's secret safe because she doesn't want to hurt Nick's family or Noah.... Phyllis and Chloe planned the set-ups for the guys' shoots. Chloe suggested they play on the brothers' rivalry and shoot Cane and Billy at odds with each other. Phyllis loved the idea. The guys then changed into boxing gear — shorts and no shirt. Phyllis implored them not to really engage in physical contact. Cut to a photo montage as Cane and Billy fake sparred! Chloe and Phyllis enjoyed the show. After, Chloe questioned Billy about his fight with Cane; he explained that Cane was defending Chloe's honor.

After the shoot, Billy met with Lily at the coffeehouse. She confessed that she had some reservations about their relationship; he was surprisingly understanding. She asked if they could "keep things chill" and not be too serious. He responded by kissing her.... Chloe thanked Cane for standing up for her with Billy. Cane explained that he did so since she's the mother of his child.

Phyllis invited Jack to pose for the issue. Jack agreed. However, he believed that Nick would eventually see the "real" devious Phyllis. Later, Jack did his Sinatra-inspired shoot for the magazine.

Sharon was surprised to "run into" Brad in New York. She couldn't believe that they coincidentally bumped into each other. Nick returned and explained that his flight home was cancelled. He was shocked to see Brad there.