In the church basement, Juanita complained about the weddings taking so long to start. Hench explained that they needed to stay in the basement until everyone left. Juanita bellowed about getting revenge on Pilar. "I want my revenge NOW!" she yelled, channeling her best Veruca Salt. Juanita sensed something was wrong upstairs.

Esme and Tabitha barged into the church to find almost all of Harmony dead — and Viki and Vincent standing over the bodies. "I see dead people," Esme cried. She then grieved as she realized all of her friends and lovers were gone. Tabitha got ready to flee, but Esme implored her to stay and save everyone. Vincent mocked the idea of Tabby fixing everything and called her "old." "As a blue-ribbon winner of the genetic mutation society, perhaps you should leave name-calling to others," the witch retorted. An earthquake then rocked the church. "It's the dark side!" announced Tabitha, explaining that her presence there was wreaking havoc with time and space. "All I wanted was for you to bring a few dead people back to life. Is that too much to ask for?" said Esme. Esme implored Tabby to stop the quake; the witch agreed to try a spell and began chanting over the bodies. As she did so, she was zapped by a bolt of lightning and lost her strength. Tabby then approached a huge cross and prayed to God to help her. She offered up her powers as a sacrifice if he saved everyone. Bolts then began to shoot out of her arms and zap everyone. "What was that?" Viki asked. "Goodness," Esme replied. Everyone soon began waking up; Julian recalled that Viki and Vincent had poisoned them. Later, Esme searched for Tabitha and found her seemingly lifeless body pinned to the wall next to the cross. Tabby soon regained consciousness, but no longer had her powers. Esme tried to comfort her friend and called Tabby an angel. Tabitha asked Esme not to tell everyone what happened, especially since she no longer had powers to protect herself.

Later, as everyone continued to get well, Juanita came upstairs, disguised as a nun, and offered to help the crowd. To herself, she looked forward to her bomb exploding and killing Pilar and her family. "My family can finally rest in peace when yours is in pieces," she thought.

Tabby returned home and prepared to leave town. Unfortunately and invisible Endora couldn't break her spell. Tabitha panicked over not being able to help her daughter — or hug her. Aww. Endora assured her that they'd figure things out together.

Luis told Sheridan how important she was to him. Sheridan got excited until he clarified that it was her friendship that was important.... Theresa fantasized about reuniting with Ethan.... Sam went to arrest Viki and Vincent (but requested Luis's help in doing so). First, Esme listed all of Viki's other murders. Sam was thrilled to have actually solved a case! Uh, go, Sam? Viki then flipped out and Sam grabbed her. "Breathe in, breathe out," Sam advised, trying to calm her. Ha! Vincent then revealed that Tabitha was the one who saved them — and is a witch. Julian and Esme quickly denied it. Luis accused the pair of trying to use an insanity defense... Ethan approached Gertrude and insisted that she was Theresa. Gert denied it.... Pilar wondered why the nun looked so familiar.... Viki and Vincent were taken away. Vincent vowed to return when everyone least expected it.