Tabitha was miffed that Endora wouldn't help with the packing, as she was anxious to get out of Harmony before disaster struck. Esme showed up with champagne, saying she skipped the rehearsal dinner because Julian and Eve had reconciled. The Magic Bowl started to bubble with a message for Esme that she didn't want to hear. The message revealed that Viki killed her parents. Esme refused to believe it. Tabitha pointed out that the hard truth was that Viki was a serial killer, and she was about to strike again. Tabitha was sympathetic to Esme's plight, as the stunned aunt watched Viki's reign of terror play out in the bowl. "It's true," she cried. "My sweet, innocent niece is a serial killer!" The bowl had one last secret for Esme — it revealed the poisoned guests at the rehearsal dinner. Esme fainted. When she came to, she rushed over to the church. Endora, who still wouldn't materialize, told her mother that they had to help Esme. Tabitha was reluctant; she still wanted to get out of Harmony as soon as possible.

At the rehearsal dinner, Sheridan decided to let Fancy die by allowing her to eat the poisoned mushroom sauce, but decided then she'd speak up in order to save everyone else. Viki then announced that dinner was served.

Ethan was relieved when "Gertrude" arrived at the dinner, unaware that someone had just tried to kill her. Gwen invited "Gertrude" to join her and Ethan in order to torture her. Gwen assured that someday "Gertrude" would have a man of her own, one just as wonderful as Ethan.

When Eve and Ivy discussed Pretty being institutionalized, Eve mentioned that mental instability runs in the family with some of the Crane women. Ivy disagreed, citing Sheridan as an example of a woman with a healthy mental outlook. Meanwhile, Sheridan was silently waiting for Fancy to keel over. In the meantime, she called the women on their own track records when it came to men. Eve and Ivy were contrite afterward. Eve noted that, "Love based on anything but the truth is doomed," giving Sheridan hesitation about letting Fancy die so she could be with Luis. Sheridan had a change of heart and as everyone was about to eat, she said she had an announcement. Just then, the disguised Vincent sneaked up behind her and poked a gun in her back, stating that if Sheridan spoke out, he'd shoot. Sheridan then said she wanted to propose a toast. After her speech, Vincent and Viki escorted Sheridan out and locked her in a closet. Then they skipped back to the reception. Vincent put on some music to mute Sheridan's pleas for help.

As everyone was about to eat again, Noah stood up and proposed a toast. Luis noticed Sheridan was gone and thought he heard her crying for help. He asked Fancy to check the ladies' room for Sheridan. Viki told the couple that Sheridan got a call and had some business to take care of.

Soon Julian began to cough, and other guests started feeling queasy and dizzy. As everyone got worse, Sam tried to phone for help but collapsed. Vincent pulled off his wig, shocking the police chief. Viki then announced her duplicity, as well. Eve was horrified. When she didn't collapse, Vincent went to strangle his mother. Ethan then collapsed and Gertrude, who hadn't eaten anything, rushed to his aid and realized he had stopped breathing.