Tabitha continued to search her home for an invisible Endora. She feared they wouldn't make it out of Harmony in time to escape the impending disaster. Juanita, a.k.a. "Mrs. Hernandez" entered and Tabby asked her to alter her if she saw anything moving that wasn't supposed to be moving. After Tabitha left, Juanita gleefully engaged in her favorite hobby: plotting Pilar's demise. Soon, Juanita's henchman joined her and Juanita introduced him simply as "Hench." "We're not all Carlos and Juan," he replied. Juanita explained that Hench was there to help her move in. Tabitha was upset when they shared that they planned to renovate the home ‹ and warned them to stay out of the basement. The witch then realized it was their home and not hers. "Blow it up, if you'd like," she stated. "I will," thought Juanita, as she envisioned blowing up Pilar. Later, Endora finally let Tabitha know where she was, but refused to leave town because they needed to help their friends. Tabitha pointed out that they'd all die.

At the Crane mansion, Fancy and Luis were shocked when Sheridan ripped off Pretty's fake scar. Sheridan compared the makeup to that of a particular sci fi show's. Pretty shrieked in response and demanded she get her "scar" back. "It's my friend, it never leaves me," she babbled. Sheridan explained that she suspected Pretty was faking; it was confirmed when she called various doctors, who revealed that Pretty's scar had indeed been healed. Pretty continued to rant and rave. Sheridan confided in Luis about how her great-grandmother went mad, so mental illness ran in her family. Sheridan then asked Luis if they could ever reunite. Luis replied that he loved her, but wanted to marry Fancy. Sheridan gave them her blessing, but admitted that it was going to be hard to give up the hope of having a future with him. Pretty suddenly pulled out a gun and held it on them. Luis took it away from her, then led her out in a straightjacket. Guess the Cranes just happened to have some leftovers lying around.

Meanwhile in the Crane library, Gwen and Rebecca prepared to out "Gertrude" as Theresa in front of Ethan. Gwen then realized that if Ethan knew Theresa was alive, he'd leave Gwen. Gwen quickly stopped Rebecca from telling the truth by smacking Rebecca. Later, Gwen realized that Theresa was keeping her identity hidden in order to hide from Juanita. Gwen planned to torture her rival. Later, Rebecca bumped into "Mrs. Hernandez," not realizing that she was Juanita, and confided in the "stranger" how she hated this woman (read: Theresa) so much she wanted to kill her. Juanita listened with interest.... Theresa sadly accepted that Gwen and Ethan were going to go through with their wedding.