At Tabitha's, Esme managed to lure an invisible Endora out of hiding by setting up some makeup for her to play with. Esme and Tabitha quietly approached the little girl and grabbed for her, but didn't catch her. They then heard Endora walking to the corner of the attic. Tabby begged her daughter to make herself visible, to no avail. The ladies relaxed for a moment. Esme was impressed when Tabby zapped them a couple of Martimmies. "It's so much fun having a witch as a friend," she gushed. "Almost as fun as having a pharmacist for a friend." They then discussed the challenges that come with caring for a child. "I've even delayed taking my morning Lithium until I've dropped Viki off at school in the morning," said Esme. "Mostly." Esme was concerned that Viki was being exposed to so much murder. Tabitha thought to herself about Viki being a killer and wondered if the teen was connected to the disaster approaching Harmony. Tabitha started to tell Esme the truth about Viki, but Esme was asleep and didn't hear. The witch zapped Esme back into her own bed and decided to zap a certain movie star into her new friend's bed with her so that Esme wouldn't have to sleep alone.

At the Crane mansion, Ethan asked "Gertrude" if she was in love with him, but she denied it. Downstairs, Gwen and Rebecca realized that Theresa was Gertrude, and believed that Little Ethan and Pilar knew the truth. Gwen blamed Rebecca for hiring Gert. "You should be mad at Theresa for not dying," snapped Becks. "Even that shark wouldn't eat her; that should tell you something." Later, Theresa sadly packed her and Little E's things, while Ethan watched the slide show that Little E had put together.... Rebecca wanted to call Juanita to let her know about Theresa. Later, "Gertrude" and Ethan came downstairs and the ladies prepared to tell him the truth about the nanny.

Meanwhile, in Fancy's room, Pretty argued with her sister, then splashed acid in Fancy's face. Fancy screamed. Sheridan called an ambulance, while Luis cared for Fancy. Fancy then looked up and her face was fine; Pretty began to freak out, babbling about how Luis is supposed to be with her. Luis then revealed that Sheridan blocked Pretty's arm, which prevented the acid from hitting Fancy's face. Pretty tattled that Sheridan knew about her plan to hurt Fancy and hadn't warned them. Sheridan explained that she hadn't taken Pretty's threat seriously and that she just thought Pretty was blowing off steam. Luis and Fancy understood and weren't upset with Sheridan, which made Pretty even angrier. Pretty continued to mutter to herself. Fancy felt bad that her sister hated her so much and apologized to Pretty. Pretty replied that she deserved to get her revenge. Later, Sheridan announced that Pretty had a big secret — and ripped off Pretty's fake scar!

Vincent took Viki to the wharf and revealed his plan on how they'd kill everyone in Harmony by poisoning them. She was skeptical when he shared how they were going to pick poisonous mushrooms. She didn't believe they'd find 'shrooms on the docks, but Vincent found some growing beneath the boards. He explained that they'd make a sauce with the mushrooms.