At Tabitha, er, Juanita's home, Paloma searched for Roberto, fearing that Noah killed him. Noah denied it, explaining that all he did was yell at Roberto for pursuing Paloma, and then after Roberto took a swing at him, Rob jumped out the window. Paloma was angry with Noah for fighting with Roberto, but he argued that Rob was the one who'd started a fight.

Tabitha panicked when she couldn't find Endora. Turns out, Endora had made herself invisible so that they wouldn't be able to leave Harmony. Later, Esme entered the attic where Tabby was searching for her daughter and wondered what was going on. "Are you on the same prescriptions I am?" Esme asked, as she watched stuffed animals floating around. "If the world were like this all the time, I'd stay stone cold sober." Esme then saw a broomstick fly by and accused Tabitha of being a witch. Tabitha gave in and admitted it. "I'm a spell-casting, union card-carrying witch!" she announced Really, witches have unions?. Esme agreed to help Tabby find Endora if Tabitha granted her three wishes.... Meanwhile, as Tabby and Endora fought, one of Endora's spells briefly turned Noah into an ape. Later, Paloma and Noah made up.

Also at the mansion, Ethan wondered what happened to the letter he'd found from Theresa. He was glad to have "Gertrude" on hand to listen to his problems. Gert wondered why he wanted to remarry Gwen when he didn't love her. Ethan replied that he does love Gwen in her own way and wanted to marry her for the kids' sake. Gert suggested he wait to get married, but he believed he'd be "satisfied" with Gwen.... Gwen was grateful that she'd stolen the letter before he had a chance to read it. Rebecca wondered if Pilar was the person who'd written the letter, but Gwen was positive that it was Theresa's handwriting. They checked against an old letter and the handwriting checked out. Still, Gwen wondered why these letters kept popping up, especially from someone who was too young to be anticipating her death. Rebecca was also suspicious about the timeline mentioned in the note regarding Little Ethan's adoption. They realized that Theresa was alive.... Theresa decided to leave another "long-lost letter" for Ethan to find.

At the Crane mansion, Fancy and Luis relished feeling safe, now that they knew Pretty was faking her pregnancy. Fancy thought Pretty should pack her bags and head for someplace other outside of Harmony. Meanwhile, Pretty planned to splash acid in Fancy's face, despite Sheridan's pleas that she not do it. Sheridan wasn't sure if she should tell Fancy about Pretty's plan, noting that if Fancy is injured, Luis would probably leave her and Sheridan could have Luis for herself.... Back in her bedroom, Luis and Fancy had sex and he commented about how he could stare at her face forever. Later, Pretty paid Luis and Fancy a visit and refused to leave, despite them demanding that she get out. "I'm sick an tired of hearing about your damn scar," Fancy snapped. "If you hate it so much, why don't you just cut off your head?" Fancy then noted that Pretty's true ugliness is on the inside. Pretty held a vial of acid behind her back, then splashed it in Fancy's face.