In Mexico, Ethan, Luis and Miguel lamented the loss of Theresa. Luis vowed to find out why Juanita was after his family; Ethan was devastated that the love of his life was gone forever. Meanwhile, Juanita assured Gwen she was a woman of her word and begged to be untied, reminding Gwen of the consequences if she didn't: Juanita would go to prison for killing Pilar's relatives and Gwen would not only lose Ethan forever, but also go to jail for blackmail. Gwen reluctantly agreed when Miguel, Luis and Ethan suddenly walked in; Gwen covered. Then Pilar also entered, claiming she was too upset to sleep and asked about Vanessa. Miguel broke the news that they couldn't find her and Theresa was gone. Gwen assured a still tied-up Juanita that she'd come up with a plan to get them out of their current pickle.

Later, the search for Theresa was called off and she was declared dead. An outraged Pilar vowed to seek revenge on Juanita and anyone who helped her, of course.... Ethan called Gwen out on being happy that Theresa was dead, but she denied it. Meanwhile, Pilar faced off against Juanita who threatened to kill every member of Pilar's family to avenge Carlos' death.

Sheridan promised Marty that he shouldn't be afraid of his daddy marrying mean Fancy, assuring him that they were going to be a family again after Luis returned from Mexico. Meanwhile, Pretty brought her sis (who was resting on the couch) a cup of tea. Fancy was clearly confused about her behavior and marveled at how crazy she'd been acting lately. Pretty grinned as she flashed back to manipulating her sis with the controller, then fibbed that she thought it must just be stress. Pretty feigned concern and offered Fancy support while thinking snarky comments of revenge to herself. She talked Fancy out of going to see a doctor, suggesting yoga to relax instead.

Sheridan and Marty were stunned to find Fancy in the den. She tried to apologize for losing control earlier and attempted to mend fences with Marty, but he was still freaked out by her and clutched onto Sheridan, who wasn't buying the "I'm sorry" bit. Pretty grabbed for the controller, snickering that it was the perfect time for an encore performance, but she fumbled and Sheridan saw. Marty picked up the controller from the floor, much to Pretty's chagrin. Turns out, the kid mistook the controller for a video game remote so he turned on the TV, punched some buttons and started to play while (surprise, surprise) Fancy began feeling funny again and lost control of her arm. She took a swing at Sheridan and rammed herself face-first into a wall as Pretty watched on in amusement. Sheridan, meanwhile, was incredibly confused.

Back in Mexico, Luis was overcome with guilt about not saving Theresa; Miguel tried to relate. Luis got a call that Fancy had come to see him but was surprised when he opened the door. Meanwhile at the docks, Pilar informed Gwen, Ethan and Miguel that the truth about her past (the reason why Juanita was involved in Theresa's death) would be revealed...tonight!