At Tabitha's, Demon Elf returned and destroyed the kitchen. Yay, Elfie's back! Elfie vowed to make her pay for interfering with his evildoing. Kay and Tabitha entered the kitchen and wondered why it was a mess. Kay explained that her kettle suddenly exploded. Tabitha then found some finger prints and called for Elfie. "Come out, you evil little lawn gnome!" she demanded. Hey, I wonder if Elfie knows the Travelocity gnome? Tabby realized that Kay summoned "this rancid blob of road kill" with the magic bowl. Kay explained that it was an accident. Elfie then began annoying the women by clanging pots together and singing a well-known song. Kay called him "an off-key Smurf." Tabby threatened to feed Elfie to Fluffy. Tabitha wanted to use magic to get rid of him, but Kay reminded her that they couldn't. They tried to get rid of him by burning incense, but that didn't work. Suddenly, the house began shaking and Elfie began coughing —and he finally disappeared. Kay was thrilled that they'd managed to vanquish him without using magic.

At the Crane mansion, Julian, Sam and Esme tried to get some more clues about the attacker. Sam concluded that the person was coming after Esme. Julian was willing to risk his life to catch the killer by pretending to sleep with Esme. Esme was turned on by Julian's bravery and kissed him. "You know, there are some things a cop should never have to see," Sam thought to himself. After, as he skulked around the manse, Sam ran into Ivy. She began to kiss him, but he reminded her that he was on "official business." Ivy didn't care. "I have work to do," he said. "Hard work, I'll bet," she replied. They ended up sleeping together, but Sam remembered that he was supposed to be tracking the attacker. He returned to Esme's room, where she and Julian planned to get "started" on their night together. Meanwhile, Ivy waited for Sam downstairs in the living room as the attacker watched her from the doorway.

Juanita was disappointed that Pilar didn't die after the boat explosion. Luis and Miguel wondered why Juanita had issues with their mother. Juanita simply vowed (yet again) to get revenge on Pilar.... Meanwhile, by the wharf, Ethan tried to save Theresa, who was flailing around in the water with the sharks.... Gwen pleaded with Luis to rescue Ethan from the dangerous ocean waters. Juanita wondered why Ethan was so important to Gwen. Rebecca then called Gwen and was disappointed to hear that Theresa wasn't dead yet. Juanita overheard Gwen talking to Rebecca when Gwen accidentally put her phone on speaker and realized that the ladies had been blackmailing Pilar. Rebecca was alarmed to hear that Gwen was with Juanita and hung up. After, Juanita informed Gwen that she knows her secret. She threatened to expose Gwen and Rebecca if Gwen didn't release her. Juanita warned Gwen that she'd never be with Ethan.... In the ocean, Ethan and Theresa declared their love for one another. Ethan explained that he got a call from a mystery woman, warning him that Theresa was in Mexico. Theresa was relieved to hear that Pilar was safe. She then screamed as a shark approached them. Later, a shirtless Luis and Miguel went out in a boat to search for Ethan and Theresa. Theresa began to drift away. Ethan tried to grab her, but she disappeared from his view. Ethan cried out for her, to no avail. Miguel and Luis then retrieved a body from the water that was caught in a fish net. They brought the body back to shore.