At Tabitha and Kay's place, Kay, Miguel, Noah and Paloma tried to plan out their wedding, but had trouble agreeing on the details. Paloma then realized that they needed to come up with a date, but none of the dates were working for all four of them.

Meanwhile, Tabitha searched her home for Miguel's letter, but Endora hid it from her. Tabitha believed the note had been stuffed into a doll's head. She tried to take the toy apart but couldn't. After, Tabby came down and found the two couples together. She ruined their excited mood when she noted that most marriages end in divorce. Kay insisted that their double wedding is going to be perfect. Noah made a call to the church, but the date they agreed on was booked. Tabitha thought it was a sign. "You've already turned your backs on the church by having premarital sex," she pointed out. "Even monkeys have more control." Privately, Tabitha offered to use magic to help them out, but Miguel stopped her. "I forgot — Derwood here says magic is a no-no," Tabitha sighed. Soon after, a bat suddenly appeared in the kitchen. Noah concluded that there was magic in the house, but Kay quickly covered that it was being run by remote control. Endora helped out by suddenly making a remote appear. Later, the church called Kay and told them the date they wanted is available. Miguel accused Kay and Tabitha of using magic to make the church available, but they both denied it. "I don't know what to think," said Miguel. "Thinking has never been your forte," Tabby snapped. Kay suggested they prove their innocence by taking a test that showed if they used it. Basically, it involved shining a flashlight-type thing on their hands. Both were found innocent and Miguel apologized. He then noted that everything works out without magic.

Fancy tried to figure out why she'd suddenly become enraged while at Sheridan's cottage. Pretty, who controlled Fancy's chip, gleefully spied on her confused sister until Luis caught Pretty in the act. Pretty lied that she was worried about Fancy's behavior, which was why she was watching her. Luis praised Pretty for being so caring, despite having been at odds with her sister. After he left, Pretty prepared to make Fancy have another "outburst." Luis and Fancy met up at the Book Café and she apologized for her behavior; she then suddenly lashed out at him for having cheated on her with Sheridan. Luis was determined to find out what was wrong with her. Pretty then entered the café and Fancy lashed out at her. Luis couldn't believe that Fancy would be so nasty to her own sister. Fancy stormed out and told them to leave her alone. Luis declared Pretty to be "amazing" when she planned to see if Fancy was okay. Fancy, now suffering from a headache, took a walk to the wharf. Pretty used the chip again to make Fancy kiss Noah.

In Mexico, Juanita talked and talked and talked while holding a gun on Theresa. Juanita laughed as she planned to kill Theresa's whole family. Theresa tried to distract her by tossing an item at Juanita; this only made Juanita angrier. Theresa told Juanita to think of Jesus; Juanita then freaked out. Just then, Pilar arrived at the compound, under the assumption that Juanita would take her in place of Theresa. Juanita continued to pontificate and hold up her gun, but not actually shoot anyone. Pilar gasped and whimpered, which only fueled Juanita's ... long-winded speech. Theresa tried to save her mom, But Juanita shoved Theresa out of the way. "You did this, Pilar!" Juanita bellowed. "You took away EVERYTHING!" Juanita then explained that planning revenge on Pilar gave her life a purpose. No wonder she was so reluctant to actually kill Pilar. Juanita took Pilar and Theresa to the room where Pilar killed Carlos (and was raped by him). She then announced that she'd lied to Pilar and was planning to kill both her and Theresa. But of course, as Juanita spoke about how she longed to hear their screams of mercy, she did nada. "Nothing you say will stop me," said Juanita. Not to worry.... keeping quiet seemed to be the key here in staying alive. Juanita grabbed Theresa and held the gun to her head but then changed her mind and got out what looked like a pirate's sword instead. Cool! Juanita explained that now that she runs Carlos's business, she's respected, then broke down as she remembered her husband. Curiously, she gave the women a one-night reprieve and warned them that they'd better not try to leave the compound. She swore that she'd kill them in the morning. Pilar and Theresa sobbed and hugged each other.