Tabitha continued searching for Miguel's letter. While she was busy looking, Endora had the letter in her hand. Tabitha finally gave up, and Endora hid the letter in a doll's head.

Ethan expressed his frustration to Gwen that Theresa is MIA again. He rejected Gwen's suggestion that Theresa is off with her lover. Gwen got Ethan to realize that he should give up on Theresa. She told him she'd always be there for him, and they kissed. Meanwhile, Luis told Sheridan that Marty was finally asleep. Sheridan claimed she could kill Fancy for terrorizing Marty. She said they need to agree that Fancy is never to be anywhere near Marty ever again. Luis said they shouldn't go too far, but Sheridan insisted it is too dangerous for her to be around Marty. Luis lamented that Fancy used to be so good with Marty. He and Sheridan debated whether Fancy is just like Alistair. Ethan and Gwen arrived to see Marty, but Sheridan told them he was already asleep. Ethan asked Luis if knew Theresa's whereabouts. When Luis said no, Ethan thought it odd that Theresa wouldn't even tell her family where she went. He expressed his fear that Theresa may be in trouble, and recited all of Theresa's recent bizarre behavior. Luis then explained Fancy's own bizarre behavior. Elsewhere, Gwen told Sheridan that she and Rebecca had a hand in Theresa's troubles. Sheridan marveled that Fancy is sabotaging her relationship with Luis all by herself. The two women toasted their romantic futures. Meanwhile, Luis and Ethan resolved not to give up on Fancy and Theresa, respectively.

Noah and Paloma and Kay and Miguel tried to work out the details of their double wedding and reception. The four disagreed on everything, from music to food to wedding cake. Miguel asked the ladies if maybe they shouldn't have a double wedding after all. Kay and Paloma said they still want to do it, but Kay said they all need to compromise. They then disagreed whether to splurge on the wedding or try to cut corners and save money. Paloma called a time out and said they're all arguing over what should be the happiest day of their lives.

Theresa tried to find a way out of Juanita's place, but she was trapped. Juanita appeared, aimed her gun at Theresa and asked her if she was ready to die. Theresa tried to make her understand that she and her family have already suffered enough over the years, and recounted her family's woes. "Please, give up this idea of revenge," pleaded Theresa. "Killing my family will not bring your family back." Juanita seemed to take pleasure at hearing Theresa recount her family's misery. She asked Theresa to explain her history with Ethan from the beginning. "Maybe you can convince me to spare your life," Juanita mused. Theresa filled in told the story. "I've been through hell the past eight years," surmised Theresa. "I can see that," acknowledged Juanita, who added, "I can see that Pilar raised an exact clone of herself: a lying, scheming slut who deserves to die." Juanita aimed her gun at Theresa again, but decided to wait until Pilar arrives so Pilar can witness her daughter's execution. Juanita then got a call from Pilar, who arrived in town. Juanita offered to exchange Theresa for Pilar. Theresa yelled to her mother that it was a trap but Juanita hung up the phone before Pilar could hear her.