At the Blue Note, Gwen tried to take Ethan's mind off of Theresa and her apparent infidelity. Ivy told him he's much better off without her, and ordered a bottle of the club's best Champagne to celebrate Theresa being out of Ethan's life. Ethan told them he's in no mood to celebrate and excused himself, which gave Gwen the opportunity to fill in Ivy on what happened at the cabin. Ivy encouraged Gwen to go after Ethan and win him back, pronto. The two toasted to that idea. Ethan returned to their table and Ivy annoyed him with her continued Theresa bashing. Ethan was shocked when Gwen admitted that she never stopped loving him, despite how badly he hurt her with Theresa. Ethan and Gwen hugged while Ivy looked on smugly. Ivy pressured Ethan to apologize to Gwen for all the times he sided with Theresa over her. Gwen expressed hope that they could start over and have a future together. Ethan stopped her and clarified that he said nothing about them having a future together. He said he can't think about his future right now. Gwen said she understood but offered to always be there for him.

Theresa drowned her sorrow with a drink at the cabin. "I still can't believe he thinks I'm cheating on him," she cried to Pilar. Theresa vowed to find a way to reconcile with Ethan. Pilar felt guilty for Theresa losing Ethan, blaming Gwen and Rebecca's blackmail over Pilar's past. "I pray there's some way you can still be with him," said Pilar. Theresa was then struck with an idea for a new plan: find Juanita and convince her to end her vendetta against their family. Pilar passed out at the idea. When she came to, she warned Theresa to steer clear of Juanita or else Juanita will kill them all. "That woman will kill you in cold blood like she killed my sister and my nephews," Pilar warned. "I forbid you to go to Mexico." Theresa insisted she can't live with Ethan thinking she betrayed him. "I would rather die than live without him, so if Juanita wants to kill me, let her kill me. I'm going to Mexico." After a final plea, Theresa promised her mother she wouldn't go. With Pilar out of the room, however, Theresa booked the next flight to Mexico.

Miguel and Kay told Tabitha they need to talk to her about something and warned her she's going to hate what they have to say: Kay is going to give up her witchcraft. "But magic's in your DNA," Tabitha declared. "How will you ever be happy denying your true nature?" Kay insisted she wants to make Miguel happy, even if it means giving up her witchcraft. Miguel then asked Tabitha if she would give up using it, too. Tabitha refused, but Miguel insisted that he and Kay couldn't get married until and unless she does. Tabitha admonished Miguel for bringing her into his relationship with Kay and accused him of being on a power trip. Miguel insisted if she stops her magic, all the bad things will stop happening in Harmony. Tabitha countered that they have all the mortals to thank for the bad things happening in town. Miguel freaked out when Endora made her own display of magic, and told Kay he can't marry her. Miguel told Tabitha he wrote a letter that would out Tabitha as a witch if anything ever happened to him. Her back against the wall, Tabitha reluctantly agreed to live a magic-free life. As Kay and Miguel made wedding plans, Tabitha admitted to Endora that she lied to Miguel about stopping their magic.

Sam welcomed Jessica and her baby home. He vowed to keep them both safe from Spike. Sam and Jessica bonded as they spent time with her baby. When Sam excused himself to get a room ready for the baby, Spike surprised Jessica and warned her not to scream. Spike warned her that the last time he was in jail he escaped, and threatened to escape again with Alistair's help and sell her baby on the black market if Jessica let Sam arrest him. Spike then hid when Sam returned with a bottle for the baby. When Sam stepped out again Jessica told Spike to leave but he refused. He told Jessica to give the baby his real first name, Herbert, as the baby's middle name. Sam walked in, but Spike was able to hide in the nick of time. With Spike watching from the other room, Jessica told Sam that the baby's middle name will be Herbert.