Esme panicked as she tried to call 911. She checked for a pulse on Jake and didn't find any. "That's three in a row," Esme freaked. Meanwhile, Kay did her best to cast the right spell to prevent Fancy from seeing Luis and Sheridan together. Kay admonished Tabitha (who was still in the paper bag) for her machinations. Kay looked into the bowl of water, and saw she had transported Luis and Sheridan back to Sheridan's cottage, where they got into an argument over finding Marty. Sheridan blamed Luis for not believing in her in time, while Luis accused Sheridan of always blaming everything on Fancy. Kay was excited that she succeeded, but then realized she transported Fancy into Esme's room with Jake. Esme explained to a horrified Fancy that Jake is dead. Fancy asked Esme what she did to Jake. Esme explained that she was having a consensual S&M encounter with him when he began coughing and choking, then he passed out and died. Esme and Fancy were at a loss as to who could have murdered Jake — and why. Fancy said she'd conduct a preliminary sweep of the room to search for evidence before forensics arrives. Esme discovered the pin on the bed and the pin prick on Jake's arm. Fancy looked for more clues around the bed.

Kay brainstormed for a new way to get Miguel and Endora back. Ivy and Sam entered and Kay covered up her supernatural shenanigans. Sam told Kay they got the results back on the blood they found on the kitchen floor. "It doesn't look good for you, Kay," Sam warned — the blood turned out to be human. "The lab is testing it now trying to find a match." Ivy suggested it belonged to Tabitha, Miguel or Endora, as Ivy accused Kay of murdering them. After Sam and Ivy excused themselves Kay monitored the bowl of water to watch Luis and Sheridan argue further. From insider her paper bag Tabitha cast a spell to make Sheridan chill out and stop arguing. Luis then said he was going to find Fancy and make sure she's OK. As he prepared to leave, he tripped over a trunk that had materialized on the floor of Sheridan's cottage. They investigated the trunk, and thanks to Tabitha's magical intervention, they shared a heartwarming walk down memory lane which culminated in a passionate kiss.

Sam and Ivy returned and Sam had more questions for her Kay, who insisted she didn't kidnap or murder anyone. Sam reprimanded Ivy for interrupting his investigation with her own questions. Ivy accused Sam of having a blind spot where Kay is concerned. Kay then looked in on Fancy and Esme and was aghast to learn that the fingerprints Fancy lifted at the crime scene belonged to Kay. Kay became livid at Tabitha for trying to frame her for all the murders in order to blackmail her.

At the hospital, Julian gave Eve some coffee. She thanked Julian for the pep talk and declared she was going to get clean — no more booze and pills — and conceded that her visions of Vincent was just guilty feelings. Dressed in OR scrubs, Vincent eavesdropped on their conversation through the door, as Eve resolved not to let what happened to Vincent destroy her or her future. A frantic Theresa and Ethan brought baby Jonathan into the ER with Gwen in tow. The nurse explained his 105 temperature was very serious and said she had paged Dr. Russell, while Gwen tried to downplay the seriousness of it all. Rebecca joined them and asked why Ethan was comforting Theresa and not Gwen. "How could you let this happen?" asked Rebecca. Gwen assured Rebecca she spoke to Pilar to make sure Theresa keeps her distance. Dr. Russell told Ethan and Theresa she got Jonathan's fever down a couple degrees but was still searching for the cause of the fever. Theresa and Ethan begged for reassurances. Eve remained noncommittal, but assured she was doing everything she could. She upset them when she suggested that they could always pray. Vincent eavesdropped on them and resolved to kill Jonathan and frame Eve for his death. Just then Julian came up behind Vincent, but he was interrupted by Eve before he could see it was Vincent. Eve broke the news to Julian that Jonathan's fever wasn't coming down. Julian reassured Eve of her competency as a doctor, and offered to get her something to eat. While he stepped out, Vincent gaslighted Eve by casting his voice into her office. In emotional desperation, Eve pulled out her bottle of booze from her desk and began drinking again. She then put the cap on the bottle and tried to pull herself together. Eve popped a breath mint and resolved to overcome her hallucinations. The ER nurse then called and told Eve that the IV wasn't working to bring down Jonathan's fever. The nurse confirmed with Eve to go ahead and administer the prescription Eve wrote for him. Meanwhile Vincent tampered with the prescription and upped it to a lethal dosage. Julian returned with clam chowder for Eve and detected that she'd been drinking again. She told him she heard Vincent again. Julian suggested she find some other way to deal with her guilt. Eve wanted to go to the ER to check on Jonathan but Julian worried that others would discover she'd been hitting the bottle. Back in the ER, Ethan thanked Theresa for her support and asked her what she had planned to tell him. Theresa stalled to buy some time. Ethan swore on his son's life he won't be angry with Theresa. With that level of assurance Theresa prepared to tell Ethan, while Vincent observed the nurse administering the lethal dose to Jonathan.