Bess answered the Brennans' door to Brody and calmly informed him that no one is going to take baby Chloe away from her. He grabbed Bess in an effort to get through to Jessica, but Mr. Brennan approached with a rifle. She used Phil and Cindy's story about the state taking away Nash to get Mr. Brennan to trust her. Brody backed away, while Bess urged Phil to shoot him. Brody tried to dissuade Phil from making a huge mistake, but Cindy came up behind him and knocked him out with a vase. While Cindy was checking on him, Bess suddenly reverted to Jessica.

Stacy told Stan that she'd give him the money if he agreed to punch her. She even handed him a pair of leather gloves, promising that there'd be no evidence to connect him to the assault. Afterward, she immediately had a shiner around her eye. Stan walked off with the money, but told her she always has a job in Vegas. Stacy claimed that she had moved on with her life.

Schuyler, Rex and Gigi continued their conversation in the park, where Rex accused Schuyler of stealing Stacy's money. When Rex returned home, he noticed that Stacy seemed upset and asked her to tell him what's going on. When she turned around, he immediately saw the black eye and asked who did that to her. She told a whole long story about Stan's threats. Rex assumed that Stan had seen him with Gigi at the park and immediately blamed himself for Stan attacking her. She managed to get Rex to give her a massage, and it was clear that he was playing right into her hands.

Back at Schuyler's, he and Gigi lamented that Stacy and Rex are not acting like the people they fell in love with, respectively. Schuyler checked the refrigerator and noticed that Stacy's blood samples were missing. Gigi started to wonder if Schuyler was making this whole thing up. He assured her that he wasn't, and guessed that Stacy (the only person other than Roxy who has keys) took the bag of blood. Gigi apologized for doubting him, then wondered who really did save her child's life.

Starr asked Cole why he was so quiet. He said he was happy to hear the news about Hope and would be in touch after his drug test. Starr sat in the foyer wringing her hands, while Michael and Marcie waited in the living room with John and Todd for word of Hope's whereabouts. As Blair and Starr recalled the day Hope was born, Todd overheard Starr say that she wished her dad was there for her that day. Meanwhile, Todd managed to make Marcie and Michael feel so uncomfortable that they decided to wait at home. As soon as they were gone, Todd got up to go see Té, but Blair suggested that he stay. Starr expressed her confusion over the situation but said she didn't blame Todd for what happened with the baby switch. Back at the Angel Square Hotel, Michael was elated but Marcie wondered if the news about Hope was a good thing.

Marty accompanied Cole to the rehab center for his drug test. During a private chat with Rachel, he revealed what he'd just learned about his baby and admitted to being concerned about who would raise Hope if she returned. Marty ran into John in the parking lot and asked if he has an answer to her question, but he didn't. He gave her some comforting words about Cole, while Rachel challenged Cole to admit what he really wants for Hope.

Jessica rushed to an unconscious Brody's side and showed genuine concern for the boyfriend she wanted to get rid of five minutes earlier. When the Brennans realized that Jessica didn't even know her they were, they began to call the hotline, but Bess prevailed. After cutting the phone line, she grabbed the baby and wished them well. Just as she was about to walk out the door, however, police swarmed the house.