As Cole walked Starr up to Todd's front door, she admitted to having a feeling that everything was about to change. Inside, they were both shocked and disturbed to find Kyle, who lied that he works for a babysitting service. His story didn't exactly convince Cole, who told Starr to go upstairs and make sure her brothers are okay.

Natalie and Jared returned home from their quickie wedding and expressed their fears over things to come. Brody pressed his luck by stealing a few more kisses before Jessica dismissed her secret lover. Upstairs, Rebecca crept into Chloe's nursery and told the baby that she's in the wrong house. Jared carried Natalie over the threshold and came face-to-face with Brody. The newlyweds demanded to know what he was doing there so late. Jessica, meanwhile, went upstairs to check on a colicky Chloe and asked what woke her up, unaware that Rebecca was hiding behind the door. Jessica came back downstairs and was forced to confess to her sister and Jared that she's dating Brody. Natalie nearly slipped about the baby when she expressed her concern for Jessica's mental state but the subject was successfully altered when Jess noticed Natalie's wedding ring.

John's hallucinated pal Pete (his father's former partner) guided him as he attempted to drive while Botoxicated. Pete prompted him to figure out where Powell might have brought Marty. John suspected that Kyle might have an idea, and phoned Rebecca's brother, just as Fish arrived at Todd's house. Starr came back downstairs with Jack, who was too scared to speak. Kyle was backed into a corner. John arrived and tried to get through to Jack by showing him photos of Rebecca and Powell. Jack recognized them and revealed that Powell took Blair, Todd and Téa somewhere.

Powell forced Blair and Téa into the basement at the frat house, and when Téa tried to run back upstairs, Powell fired a gun at her. Téa began to scream and tumbled down the stairs. She was only shot in the arm. Powell knocked the valve off the boiler and left the two women to die there. Blair stuffed a towel into the opening of the boiler, then boosted a reluctant Téa up to the window. Both women fell on top of each other, but Blair insisted that they try it again. When Téa fell down a second time and passed out, Blair yelled at her to wake up. Téa came to and was nearly as hysterical as Blair, who was desperate to get out of there for her children's sake.

Meanwhile, Marty started to have memories of the night she was raped in Kevin's room. “I remember you raping me right here,” she whispered to Todd. She described what she was seeing and he asked her various questions to help jog her memory. She remembered Todd awkwardly approaching the bed, and afterward, she was too traumatized to move. Todd urged her to continue searching her mind so that she could recall the good things, too. She reminisced about the fairytale-like romance she had with Patrick and giving birth to Cole.

Rebecca arrived at the KAD house with Chloe and told Powell that there's a very special reason why the baby is there. Back at Llanfair, Jessica suddenly had a flash of saying “Why aren't you crying, baby?” at the cottage, so she ran upstairs to check on Chloe, only to find her crib empty. Back at the KAD house, Powell brought the baby to a stunned Marty.