At Company, Natalia was in the bathroom and wondered why she got sick. Buzz groused about his broken oven. Liv feared Nat's overworking herself. She said she's going to bake cookies for the church and hopes that it help make her feel better. Meanwhile, Rafe asked Frank who he blames regarding his botched wedding to Natalia and urged him not to lie to himself about his feelings for Nat.

At Cross Creek, Reva was stunned (and mostly annoyed) to see that Josh had stayed the night in his car outside her house to keep an eye on her. She left him a cup of coffee and a note that read, "Where's my husband, jack ass?" Later, Buzz and Lillian picked up Reva for lunch at Towers as Josh watched from afar. He promptly followed them to the restaurant where he sat at a table across the room. Reva was angry, saying Josh is just using Jeffrey's absence to get closer to her. Afterward, she was miffed that she had to lie to Buzz and Lillian about being okay about Jeffrey being MIA.

Mallet caught Shayne and Marina discussing the Edmund/Dinah/Jeffrey situation but they quickly covered. Mallet and Shayne started bickering after Mallet accused everyone of lying to him. Shayne wondered why Mallet thinks Dinah is guilty and suggested that perhaps she knows Eddie's whereabouts and that's why she left town. Shayne was determined to help Mallet find Dinah and Jeffrey (and protect baby Henry) but Marina implored him to walk away. After Shayne departed, Mallet asked Marina what she and Shayne were discussing regarding "our son." Marina made up a flimsy story but Mallet didn't buy it. Then he called out Marina for lying about Henry's paternity and admitted he figured out that Henry is Shayne's. He implored her to stop lying. She broke down in tears and apologized, then tried to plead her case about why she did it. Then she assured Mallet that Shayne doesn't want to be Henry's dad. She explained she was trying to protect Mallet's feelings. Mallet was surprisingly understanding. Meanwhile, an angry Shayne confronted Josh about the web of lies associated with Edmund's murder, including the one that Jeffrey is guilty, and wondered when it will all stop because he's sick of it and fears for Dinah's safety.

Back at the farmhouse, Nat told Father Ray she's been feeling ill. He wondered if her questionable lifestyle choices might be responsible for her turned stomach and suggested she stop her relationship with Olivia. She refused to believe that God is punishing her for who she loves, adding that the decisions she's made have made her a stronger person. Meanwhile, Olivia ran into Doris at Towers who'd just had a rift with Ashlee. La Wolfe admitted she's been on edge with her daughter lately because she's lying to her about her own sexuality. Liv encouraged Doris to tell Ash the truth.

Shayne paid Reva a visit at home and told her that Dinah is with Jeffrey. He was angry and said he hopes Jeffrey comes back because Dinah's life is in his hands. Later, Shayne confronted his dad (again) for stalking Reva. Josh explained that he's doing it for Jeffrey, adding that her safety is his chief concern.

Back at Company, Ashlee apologized to Doris about their fight. Doris was emotional as she was about to tell Ashlee that she's a lesbian but stopped when Ash said she had to run.... Olivia ran into Rafe at the market. He was short with her and refused to listen. Liv advised him to think of his mother, even if he does hate Liv. Rafe pointed out that his mom isn't the person she used to be and wondered what will happen to Nat when she has to answer to God. Liv pointed out that Nat has stood by Rafe through his prison stint and then some. She urged him to get past whatever beef he has with her now. Then she said that his surprising reaction has made their relationship stronger. Rafe was clearly uncomfortable. "I can't believe I'm having this conversation," he said and stormed off.... Nat and Blake went over work things at the Beacon. Blake took a call while Nat was overcome with nausea again. Blake wondered if Nat might be pregnant.