While Harley and Daisy cleaned up, Daisy spotted a pair of men's underwear. Harley was mortified thinking her daughter would know she had been sleeping with a new man, but she was relieved when Daisy assumed they were Gus' undies. Later, at the station, Harley called Cyrus to tell him she missed him and loved him. On her way out, she overheard Marina on the phone with Cyrus telling him the same thing.

When Harley went for a jog to blow off steam, she ran into Gus. The two sat down by a stream to have a chat, and quickly began to reminisce on their good times. Caught up in the moment, Harley leaned in and kissed Gus. "I miss my old friend," Gus said. "I do, too," Harley replied before getting up and walking away.

When Harley returned home, she got a message from Cyrus saying he was back in town. She hurried to Main Street to greet him, but when she arrived he wasn't there. While hiding in the shadows, Marina watched Harley.

At the lighthouse, Cassie told Josh that she and Reva were making progress in patching up their relationship. Josh said he had a meeting at the church, but he wasn't sure what to expect. He asked her to go with him, but Cassie spotted Will hiding in the bushes and made up an excuse to stay behind. After Josh left, Cassie played with Will until Jeffrey found them. He told Cassie she needed to return Will to jail immediately, or he would. Cassie took Will back to the courthouse for a hearing with the judge. She told the judge how Will suffered when he was away from her, and how she needed to be able to help him through his difficult times. After her emotional testimony, Cassie called Josh to give him good news, and Josh told her he wanted to have a party to celebrate the fact that he'd gotten his congregation back.

Meanwhile, Jonathan tried to convince Mel to represent him in a custody battle for Sarah. Mel advised that his reputation and priors would make it too difficult to defend his rights for full custody and declined to represent him. Meanwhile, at the park, Lizzie told Bill she was afraid to lose Sarah. "Let me get your daughter back for you," Bill offered, asking Lizzie to trust him. Lizzie wanted to, but wasn't sure she could. Wanting to put his plan into motion right away, Bill went to Reva, asking her if she would be on his side in the war against Jonathan. Reva reminded Bill that Jonathan was her son, and she would always help Jon in whatever way he needed. Bill urged Reva to do what was best for Sarah.

At the motel, Jonathan took Sarah so they could hide out until Reva could bring them the supplies they needed. While Jonathan put Sarah down for a nap, Lizzie surprised him by showing up in a sexy little number. Jonathan wondered why Lizzie wanted to see him since he'd recently kidnapped her and dumped her in the woods. Lizzie claimed she loved being with him, and she touched him and whispered in his hear to get him in the mood. They began kissing and making out, but Jonathan soon figured out that Lizzie was trying to seduce him to get Sarah. He kicked her out in her underwear. As Lizzie once again walked down the road in the cold, Bill showed up and asked her what happened. Lizzie explained that she was trying to seduce Jonathan so she could tie him up and take Sarah. Bill asked Lizzie if she would have slept with Jonathan. When Lizzie said yes, Bill got angry and drove away, leaving her standing half-naked by the side of the road.