Marina and Cyrus ran into Judge Brennan on Main Street. Cyrus smiled uncomfortably as Marina suddenly asked the judge to marry them today. Meanwhile at the beacon, Harley caught Remy leaving a fake note from immigration service for Cyrus and realized Marina had set up the scheme to get Cyrus to marry her. Later, Harley confronted Marina, who confessed to the misdeed but tried to rationalize, admitting that she feared losing Cyrus and was jealous of how close he is to Harley. Guilt-ridden, Harley consoled her niece and promised her that she has nothing to worry about.

Beth paid Josh a visit at St. Mark's, saying she feared Alan would use Sarah's memorial service to make a dastardly move and warned Josh about agreeing to oversee the service. Then, she shared that Alan had invited her and Rick to his island house afterward.

Outside the Bauer cabin, Reva attempted to distract Alan from seeing baby Sarah in the back seat of her car by pulling up the hood and claiming she was having car trouble. When Alan offered to help, Reva knocked him over the head with the car's hood and quickly took off.

Lizzie was stunned to see Jonathan, who'd saved her from getting hit by an oncoming car. When Bill ran up, he made sure Lizzie wasn't injured and confirmed to her that Jon really is alive. "Long time no see," Jon quipped. She broke into tears and hugged Jon. Then she asked about Sarah, but Jon said the baby didn't survive the crash. Outraged, Lizzie railed at Jon for letting Sarah die. Jon begged Lizzie not to tell Alan that he is alive, then assured her that Sarah was happy during her final moments. Lizzie pleaded with Jon not to leave, saying he is the only thing she has left to remind her of Sarah. Next, they sat at the side of the road while Jon and Lizzie shared a sweet moment remembering their baby. Bill, however, had some terse words for Jon and tried to get Lizzie to turn against her ex before dragging her away.

Back at St. Mark's, Reva (with Sarah in tow) was waiting for Jon to return when Josh walked in and immediately recognized the child. Reva blabbed the truth to Josh, who was elated that Jon and Sarah are still alive. He promised to help Reva, but encouraged her to tell Lizzie the truth about her daughter. Later, Jon arrived (armed with a candlestick holder) and was about to hit Josh when Reva stopped him. Then Josh and Reva urged Jon to stay in town, to no avail.

Marina admitted the truth about the immigration info to Cyrus, who was hurt by the lie. Then Alan phoned Marina, requesting Reva's arrest for assault and gazed at Sarah's doll that he found.... Cyrus told Harley that his nups to Marina were postponed. When Marina came home, Cyrus had moved out.

Lizzie and Bill returned to the cabin. Lizzie 'fessed up about the pregnancy set up and broke down as she told Bill she just wants to be a mother. When Bill tried to put the moves on Lizzie, she blasted him for his insensitivity about Sarah. Jon, meanwhile, watched a suffering Lizzie from the cabin's window.