Alone in his hospital room, Dominic and Olivia expressed their affection for each other — then she turned to see Sonny standing in the door, looking quizzical. Dominic told Sonny he's ready to report to work, but Sonny told him to rest. Sonny reported to Olivia that Johnny was shot and is in Mercy. Olivia gasped and ran out. At the prison, Anthony accused Claudia of being disappointed that Johnny didn't die because she's an "avaricious little viper." Anthony gloated that when Sonny finds out she's responsible for Michael's shooting, he will execute them both. "Your fixation on your brother is sick," Anthony charged, adding that she acts "like a jealous lover." Claudia slapped his face, then realized he was pushing her buttons. She promised that Johnny would help her kill him, because Johnny knows Anthony is responsible. At Mercy, Johnny told Jason he replaced Dominic at the last moment. Jason wondered if Dom set up Johnny. Suddenly Olivia arrived and blubbered all over Johnny — while an annoyed Sonny watched. Later, alone, she confessed how upset she was over his shooting. She recalled their first kiss and every time they made love. She confessed she doesn't want to be casual anymore. "I'm glad you said that," he smiled. Then Claudia burst in and demanded that Olivia leave. Johnny insisted Liv stay. Claudia was incredulous, then Olivia started yelling at Claudia — who slapped her across the face! Liv slapped her back, and they started to tangle. Then Johnny coded. Later, after a doctor had restored order and thrown the battlers out, Sonny wanted to question Johnny, but both Claudia and Liv barred him from the room. Olivia threatened to tell the cops everything she knows, so Sonny left — with Claudia in tow. Still later, Jason and Sonny talked about how there must be a mole in their organization that facilitated the hit. Sonny suspected Johnny, but Jason didn't. Then Sonny theorized that Anthony wanted Dom dead for switching sides. Sonny resolved to use Dominic to neutralize "that old freak."

Lulu showed up at Lucky's to grouse about Maxie turning their place into a love palace. Lulu joked about moving in with her brother, and he noted Elizabeth is back in the picture. He admitted she put off accepting his proposal. Lulu pointed out the same thing happened with Maxie and Spinelli. Lucky said almost losing Jake prompted him to hang on.

At Wyndemere, Nikolas and Lucky made love. Afterward, a pensive Liz asked, "What have I done?" "What did I just do to you?" Nik responded. "We did this together," she reminded him. Nik felt like he took advantage of her vulnerability. She admitted Jake was conceived under similar circumstances, but she knew what she was doing then, and knew what she was doing tonight. Nikolas begged her not to tell Lucky, because the revelation will hurt him (And Lucky might hurt Nik!). She warned him that secrets always come out.

Sam visited the penthouse looking for Jason, but only Maxie was there. When Spinelli did return, his shirt was covered in blood, which horrified her. Maxie scolded him for getting involved in something dangerous, then they went to her place. Later, when Jason returned, Sam noted they were all alone. Jason started kissing her, and she reciprocated.

Lulu visited Dominic, who was glad to see her, and told her Johnny was shot. Lulu checked on Johnny's condition, but didn't go to Mercy. Dom went off on a rant about Johnny getting mixed up in the mob and Sonny and Anthony. He was so passionate that Lulu pointed out he sounded like someone who wanted to take down the mob, not work in it. At Mercy, Olivia apologized to Johnny for fighting. He said he wants her by his side. Back at G.H., Elizabeth and Lucky visited Jake. Then Liz told Lucky they need couples counseling — adding, "Yes, I'll marry you."