Forums

7 replies [Last post]
KendallTroy
Offline
Last seen: 43 years 21 weeks ago
Joined: 2008-12-26
Posts:

Let's play a game....who would you Recast, who would to Return, and who would Kill for the show??

Recast: Marissa (The character has so much to offer if dhe were written and played better)

Return: Dixie!

Kill: Annie....as much as everyone hates Ryan and Greenlee...Annie is a murder and needs to go!

vtdio2162
Offline
Last seen: 43 years 21 weeks ago
Joined: 2008-08-22
Posts:

Annie was a really ggod person UNTIL Ryan decided he wanted Greenlee again. When Ryan asked Annie to marry him she said NO he talked he into it. They only made Annie bad so Rylee lloked good and some idiot and a home wrecker. I think they need to make Annie good again get Emma back and have her hook up withScott and be happy.

cararn
Offline
Last seen: 2 weeks 5 days ago
Joined: 2008-03-17
Posts:

Hmm! Annie, I don't care how they try and recon her character, she needs to go.Recast JR with someone who could be Adam's son.Return..Adam or Brooke

KendallTroy
Offline
Last seen: 43 years 21 weeks ago
Joined: 2008-12-26
Posts:

Maybe recast Adam? Who do you like they could get to take over the character?

Gator
Offline
Last seen: 1 year 46 weeks ago
Joined: 2008-04-07
Posts:

Return: Only because we're not hearing anything official, Zach Slater. He may already be returning, but I need to hear something more than "limited return".Recast: Adam Chandler. It's an almost impossible task to start over and build up a wealthy, controlling character from scratch, and AMC doesn't have enough time to make Caleb = Adam. I don't say that lightly. The clock is ticking on all soaps, and AMC can't afford to wait. David Canary did not want to be in CA, and he gave it a shot for a few months, but it's not what he wanted. Okay, let's recast with someone with experience and who can do a powerful, rich, family-oriented mogul. Every soap needs one, and Caleb isn't going to cut it. Not when he's losing fans by being a rival for Erica's affections, and when he's a newbie to start off with. Double whammy right there. Bring back Adam, pronto.Kill: I haven't watched AMC since Zen's very brief return, but IMO, Ryan Lavery has no further value to the show. I choose him over Greenlee because she's Jack's daughter and there's family and friction to be mined there. Ryan has no family connection except to Emma and Spike, and I always associate Emma with Annie, and Spike with Zach and Kendall, so no loss there. Ryan never works and shouldn't be a casino owner in any event, so bye to Ryan. I won't miss you.

Diva
Offline
Last seen: 43 years 21 weeks ago
Joined: 2008-03-17
Posts:

Gator, I agree with your choices for return and kill. I disagree about recasting Adam. IMO neither Zach nor Adam should ever be recast. Both characters are the sum total of not just the writing, but mostly how they were developed by the two amazing actors who portrayed them, Thorsten Kaye and David Canary.I think that Caleb can take Adam's place on the canvas. He is connected through Dixie to the Chandlers and though at this point in the s/l he is at war with JR and Scott, the family connection is still there. I also think that Michael Nouri is a strong enough actor to carry this off if he is given well written material and has someone like TK's Zach to interact with.Most of all I feel strongly about Ryan. He has definitely outlived his usefulness on the show and since his siblings are no longer on the show, other than Spike and Emma, he has no family connections. The way he has been written for the past few years, he is nothing more than a fickle, obnoxious self absorbed con man, who is being portrayed as some sort of white knight and not very much liked by a large portion of the audience.As far as who I would like to see recast, I would choose Marissa. Even though today I did like her standing up to JR and showing some independence and self awareness, I think the actress is too mild and juvenile for the role. Perhaps if the writing changes and gives her more teeth, I might change my mind.

cararn
Offline
Last seen: 2 weeks 5 days ago
Joined: 2008-03-17
Posts:

Quote:Maybe recast Adam? Who do you like they could get to take over the character? I don't particularly want to see Adam recast, but if he had to be, I would choose John Slattery. But unfortunately, Mad Men has him. He's probably too young anyway.

fluffyboy
Offline
Last seen: 43 years 21 weeks ago
Joined: 2010-02-04
Posts:

I would like to see Colby and Marissa recast. I would like to see Damon gone, and I would like to see Dixie return. As for John Slattery, he would probably make a terrific Adam. Not that I would like to see Adam recast.

 

tweet ticker

 
 
 
 

get sod everywhere