Before their sonogram appointment, Natalie braced herself to tell John the truth about her baby's paternity. "It's about the baby ... and Brody," she began, but was interrupted by a knock at the door. It was Marty, who wanted to know if it's true that Eli's dead. John explained what happened in Tahiti and said he was sorry that he couldn't bring Eli back alive to pay for what he did to Marty. When Marty asked why Eli pushed her, John explained that their theory was right: Eli wanted to throw John off of his trail, and that's why their baby is gone. Marty told John that he has a very good reason to move on from that, looking in Natalie's direction. Marty graciously expressed her happiness for the pair, then excused herself. John asked what it was Nat had to tell him before Marty showed up. Natalie backtracked and claimed she was just concerned about the pregnancy because of what Jessica and Brody are going through with her Rh treatment. John assured her that everything would be fine, and made her promise to let him do all the worrying from now on.

At the hospital, Jessica broke the news to Brody that her baby might not be his. Brody could hardly believe it, and Jess was forced to admit that she slept with someone else. Brody nearly exploded upon realizing it was Ford who bedded his girlfriend while she was suffering from amnesia. Jessica tearfully apologized for keeping the truth from him, but Brody remained silent. To Jess's dismay, Brody suddenly ran off, leaving her to cry over the sonogram pic of her baby. Meanwhile, Natalie and John arrived for their high-tech sonogram, which showed them the baby's face and everything. When Dr. Wright asked if they'd like to know the sex, John and Nat agreed to be surprised. John was beside himself with joy as they continued, while Nat clearly couldn't stop worrying.

At the student center, Ford slithered over to Langston as she was grappling with a map and offered to show her around, but she refused his help. James approached Starr before their first day of classes and offered to walk her, but Cole intercepted and told James to keep his distance. Langston and James both showed up for class and wondered where their teacher was. An administrator came in and announced that Ford had decided not to teach the class because of a conflict of interest. Langston tracked down Ford, who happily told her there's nothing keeping them from dating now. Meanwhile, Starr and Cole argued about him keeping what he knew about Eli from her and inadvertently putting her mom in danger. Cole insisted that he told John and that was all he could do at the time. Both tired of fighting, they agreed to call a truce. Later, however, Cole found Starr and James chatting closely in the lounge. Ford, meanwhile, was talking to Langston at the student center when Brody rushed in and knocked out Ford.

Greg was about to tell Todd something important about Téa when he received a mysterious text message. Greg revealed that Téa had experienced a "moment of clarity" in which she asked for Todd and Danielle, but would say nothing more. Todd demanded to know why Greg hadn't told him about this at the time, but Greg swore he tried to contact Todd and Dani, who were already on the plane to see Téa. They got there too late, end of story, Greg said. After Todd kicked the doctor out, Greg glanced at the text on his phone, which said, "Don't say another word." Greg nervously looked around before leaving Todd's doorstep. Todd decided to seek out Marty for some grief counseling and asked how she recovered after Patrick died. Marty urged him to focus on Dani, which Todd didn't think was very good advice, and offered to set him up with one of her colleagues. "I hate shrinks," Todd barked on his way out. Back at home, a package arrived for Todd: Téa's ashes. Greg, meanwhile, showed up at Marty's office needing to get something off his chest.